- edited 10-19-2010 10:44 PM
I have a STB connected using "HDMI to my TV" and "Component to my Slingbox". With my TV powered off, I connected to my Slingbox and set the "Aspect ratio" on the STB to either:
The blue HD light on the STB comes on and stays on. And the signal to my Slingbox stays 720p or 1080i, even when I turn the STB on or off or disconnect and reconnect to my Slingbox.
Now when I turn my TV on, everything is still OK and it continues to output 720p or 1080i on both connections (TV and Slingbox), but when I turn my TV off, it communicates to the STB over the HDMI cable and the STB switches the "Aspect ratio" to:
So now when I connect to my Slingbox (with the TV powered off), the blue HD light on the STB is off and I get a 480i signal from the Component connection. I have to go into the STB menus and set the "Aspect ratio" back to 720p or 1080i.
It's a pain in the butt to keep having to change the "Aspect ratio" of the STB back to 720p or 1080i almost every time I connect to my Slingbox.
Does anyone know a way of blocking the two-way communication that's happening over the HDMI connection? I don't want the TV sending a signal to the STB everytime I turn my TV off and switching all the STB connections back to 480i. I want the blue HD light on the STB to remain lit at all times.
10-20-2010 7:05 AM
Look on your TV for a setting that will disable the HDMI communication protocol (called Consumer Electronics Control, or CEC). Different manufacturers have different names for CEC:
Samsung - AnyNet
Sharp - AquosLink
Sony - BraviaSync
Hitachi - HDMI-CEC
Pioneer - KuroLink
Toshiba - RegzaLink or CE-Link
Onkyo - RIHD
LG - SimpLink
Panasonic - VieraLink, HDAVI Control, and EZ-Sync
Philips - EasyLink
Mitsubishi - NetCommand
- edited 10-23-2010 12:29 PM
Thanks for the response SomeJoe7777. I looked at the settings on my Sony TV (model KDL-32M4000) and couldn't find anything concerning "BraviaSync". But in the Setup of the TV, I did find the setting "Control for HDMI". The description for the setting reads "Allows the TV to control compatible HDMI devices".
I tested with "Control for HDMI" set to "On" and "Off", but it doesn't change the problem I'm having. When I turn my TV off, the STB switches to 480i and the blue HD light goes out. So my Slingbox (Component connection) is no longer HD or widescreen until I either turn the TV back on or go into the STB menus and change the "Aspect Ratio" back to "1080i on high-definition screens".
Does anyone else know a way to stop the two-way communication happening over the HDMI cable?
10-23-2010 12:55 PM
You might want to try using component to both the Slingbox and the TV then, and remove the HDMI cable.
All you would need for this is to use 3 of these adapters from Monoprice.com, and the appropriate component cables.
Because U-Verse HD video does not contain any 1080p content, and is not a pristine source like Blu-Ray, you will not notice any difference in picture quality between HDMI and component.
10-23-2010 3:55 PM
Thanks for the suggestions! Unfortunately, my TV is on a wall mount and component cables wouldn't work very well. The HDMI cable goes through the wall and looks much nicer on the back of the TV.
I was hoping for an adapter or something that would just block the two-way communication, but allow audio and video from the STB to the TV. Or a way to fix the STB so it doesn't always switch everything to 480i when you power off the TV.
Again, thanks for the suggestions!