- AT&T Forums Home
- /
- Wireless Forums
- /
- Wireless Account and Billing
- /
- General Care and Support
- /
- Re: Wireless Customer Service Complaint
- Subscribe to RSS Feed
- Mark Topic as New
- Mark Topic as Read
- Float this Topic to the Top
- Bookmark
- Subscribe
- Printer Friendly Page
Wireless Customer Service Complaint
- Mark as New
- Bookmark
- Subscribe
- Subscribe to RSS Feed
- Highlight
- Email to a Friend
- Report Inappropriate Content
08-14-2012 03:01:13 AM
I was sent an email today saying that my son's phone would now be charged for a data plan because he is using an iPhone. He has had this phone for three weeks and has used ZERO data. I wanted to know why I was being forced to subscribe to a service that he is not using.
When I called in Customer Service Rep Joceyn R. told me that she could not take off the data plan but did not say why. I asked to be transferred to a supervisor and was given to Denise. This is where my troubles began.
Denise was one of the rudest supervisors I have dealt with in my whole 56 years on this earth. She said that if my son had an iPhone he had to have a wireless plan, no ifs ands or buts. It did not matter if he used/wanted the service or not.
I was naturally put off by her dismissive response. When I questioned this policy, Denise accused me of shouting at her while I was not (my voice may have been raised somewhat but I was far from shouting). She interrupted me continuously. She started yelling at me. When I asked her if she was yelling at me she said "yes." (Guess it's okay to her to do it and for to imagine me doing it.) She said that I had to listen to her and that she was through talking with me unless I would be quiet. She would ask the questions. I would answer. Then she would ask the same question again in a manner that made me think that she didn't care to listen to my answer because she obviously hadn't heard it. Her attitude did nothing but escalate the situation.
Throughout the call she kept putting me on hold: three times in a total 35 minute call. Finally she said that she would take the data off and that I could just check my online bill that it was done. When I asked for an employee number so that I could track our call she refused. She said she would do it because she was required to do so. When I said that people don't always do what is required she laughed dismissively at me. I asked again for her number and she put me on hold for the final time. After ten minutes waiting for her to come back on I hung up. Despite the time spent on the call, I never learned why the data was being forced upon me.
After being on hold for the final time I looked online to see if the data had been taken off. It had not. I had also received no email confirming the change. Obviously, Denise was not a woman of her word. I was only left to think that she purposely decided to not follow through with her "required" promise to take the data off.
I called back and got Jocelyn again. At first she would not admit that she was the same person but, after some prodding, she did admit that fact. She expained that I needed a data plan because AT&T wanted to "protect" me should my son use a lot of data. (Personally, I find it insulting to be told that I have to be protected. I have never asked to get out of my phone bill yet here I am being treated like a child. Shouldn't it be my problem if there is a high bill?) Nonetheless, Jocelyn took the data off explaining that I needed to get another phone or it would be back on in a day or two. She sent me an email and stayed on the line until I received the message in my inbox.
I am astounded that a woman like Denise would be in the position of supervising others. While I was on the call I learned that two of my lines are off contract and two are on for another year. After 15 years as an AT&T subscriber, I feel it is time to look for greener pastures. I used to have five lines; I just took off one for a child who now has her own service. I did not complain when told of the $100+ cancellation charge; after all, that was in the contract when I agreed to it.
My husband is on Verizon. Perhaps it is time that I and the kids join him over there. With any luck, I will be there in a little over a year.
The moral of the story is: When it's on the contract AT&T expects you to live up to what you signed up for. When it's not on the contract, AT&T expects you to live up to what it signs you up for.
P.S. Now that AT&T no longer owns the iPhone monopoly you would think that it would realize that there is competition out there. Guess not.
Re: Wireless Customer Service Complaint
[ Edited ]- Mark as New
- Bookmark
- Subscribe
- Subscribe to RSS Feed
- Highlight
- Email to a Friend
- Report Inappropriate Content
08-14-2012 03:17:14 AM - edited 08-14-2012 03:18:17 AM
Verizon, Sprint, ATT, all require a data plan on a smartphone - you will not be able to get around the requirement even switching to another major carrier. If you want to not be required to add a data plan, give the child a normal qmd / dumb phone qmd device. No front line csr can remove the data plan, it will automaticly be added back by the system when it detects a smarthpone and no data plan.

Re: Wireless Customer Service Complaint
- Mark as New
- Bookmark
- Subscribe
- Subscribe to RSS Feed
- Highlight
- Email to a Friend
- Report Inappropriate Content
08-14-2012 03:28:56 AM
Yes, so I will get him a dumb phone as you suggest. I was already planning to do that. But this does not negate my main complaint which was the rude treatment received by Denise; especially with regard to the failure to provide any explanation for the email announcing the unilateral data plan. Any response regarding degrading treatment, putting people into an endless hold, and yelling at them?
BTW, stating that you can't do any better is not a recipe for long term customer satisfaction. The post office used to have that attitude and look where it is today. Forcing people to purchase services they do not need or use only means that they will jump ship as soon as they can.
Re: Wireless Customer Service Complaint
- Mark as New
- Bookmark
- Subscribe
- Subscribe to RSS Feed
- Highlight
- Email to a Friend
- Report Inappropriate Content
08-14-2012 05:24:17 AM

Re: Wireless Customer Service Complaint
- Mark as New
- Bookmark
- Subscribe
- Subscribe to RSS Feed
- Highlight
- Email to a Friend
- Report Inappropriate Content
08-14-2012 07:11:10 AM
lgalluzi wrote:
Yes, so I will get him a dumb phone as you suggest. I was already planning to do that. But this does not negate my main complaint which was the rude treatment received by Denise; especially with regard to the failure to provide any explanation for the email announcing the unilateral data plan. Any response regarding degrading treatment, putting people into an endless hold, and yelling at them?
BTW, stating that you can't do any better is not a recipe for long term customer satisfaction. The post office used to have that attitude and look where it is today. Forcing people to purchase services they do not need or use only means that they will jump ship as soon as they can.
I cannot speak outside of personal expierence on dealing with att's, verizons, sprints customer service reps both in the commercial sector and private sector but I or my employees have not ever gotten a rude or obnoxious rep in all the dealings over the last few decades of service from them.

Re: Wireless Customer Service Complaint
- Mark as New
- Bookmark
- Subscribe
- Subscribe to RSS Feed
- Highlight
- Email to a Friend
- Report Inappropriate Content
08-15-2012 09:07:43 PM
I wouldn't say you're being forced to pay for services you don't need. The iPhone is a smart phone, meaning most functions on the device are powered by a data connection. If you're looking to carry an iDevice, maybe try an iPod touch? With that, you can use your home wi-fi rather than pay a carrier for data.
--
I am an AT&T employee and the postings on this site are my own and don’t necessarily represent AT&T’s position, strategies or opinions.
Re: Wireless Customer Service Complaint
- Mark as New
- Bookmark
- Subscribe
- Subscribe to RSS Feed
- Highlight
- Email to a Friend
- Report Inappropriate Content
08-16-2012 09:36:21 AM
As a consumer you should read the terms of service. The data requirement is there. It is not ATT's fault that you thought that an iPhone did not require a data plan and I am surprised that anyone agreed to remove it for you. If you are not happy with the data requirement, I would highly reccomend prepaid options. You are not being forced into anything and you have to comply with the terms of service.
I am an AT&T employee and the postings on this site are my own and don’t necessarily represent AT&T’s position, strategies or opinions.
Re: Wireless Customer Service Complaint
- Mark as New
- Bookmark
- Subscribe
- Subscribe to RSS Feed
- Highlight
- Email to a Friend
- Report Inappropriate Content
08-16-2012 11:19:18 AM
Sure, I should memorize the intricacies of the dozens of contracts into which I enter but would it kill them to remind me? Is it so hard to put a link in the email? Why not mention the iPod Touch option to a caller? Why not mention getting a different phone? Instead one is put on endless hold, ordered about, yelled and laughed at. Yet nobody cares about that I guess. Better to criticize the callee for not being a walking Perry Mason.
Again, my complaint is primarily with the "service" that was delivered. One may not have problems before but that does not mean it is smooth sailing for all.
BTW, my son took the SIM card out of his phone and, as astutely recommended above, is using it as an iPod Touch. All he wanted to do is track his workouts and it works quite fine for that. Appreciate the help on that one. I only wish that customer "care" was as helpful.








